Advantages of a one-bit quanta image sensor

In an arXiv preprint, Prof. Stanley Chan of Purdue University writes:

The one-bit quanta image sensor (QIS) is a photon-counting device that captures image intensities using binary bits. Assuming that the analog voltage generated at the floating diffusion of the photodiode follows a Poisson-Gaussian distribution, the sensor produces either a “1” if the voltage is above a certain threshold or “0” if it is below the threshold. The concept of this binary sensor has been proposed for more than a decade and physical devices have been built to realize the concept. However, what benefits does a one-bit QIS offer compared to a conventional multi-bit CMOS image sensor? Besides the known empirical results, are there theoretical proofs to support these findings? The goal of this paper is to provide new theoretical support from a signal processing perspective. In particular, it is theoretically found that the sensor can offer three benefits: (1) Low-light: One-bit QIS performs better at low-light because it has a low read noise and its one-bit quantization can produce an error-free measurement. However, this requires the exposure time to be appropriately configured. (2) Frame rate: One-bit sensors can operate at a much higher speed because a response is generated as soon as a photon is detected. However, in the presence of read noise, there exists an optimal frame rate beyond which the performance will degrade. A Closed-form expression of the optimal frame rate is derived. (3) Dynamic range: One-bit QIS offers a higher dynamic range. The benefit is brought by two complementary characteristics of the sensor: nonlinearity and exposure bracketing. The decoupling of the two factors is theoretically proved, and closed-form expressions are derived.

Pre-print available here: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2208.10350.pdf

The paper argues that, if implemented correctly, there are three main benefits:

1. Better SNR in low light

2. Higher speed (frame rate)

3. Better dynamic range

This paper has many interesting technical results and insights. It provides a balanced view in terms of the regimes where single-photon quanta image sensor provide benefits over conventional image sensors.